Subscribe to How-To Geek

Welcome to the How-To Geek Forums

We encourage you to register on our forums and post any questions you might have. The How-To Geeks monitor this forum and will respond to your question quickly.

How-To Geek Forums » Windows Vista

VISTA VS XP

(24 posts)
  • Started 1 year ago by cobija
  • Latest reply from cobija
  • Topic Viewed 1135 times

cobija
Posts: 320

im thinking of completely taking off vista and going to xp. why should or shouldnt I?

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
whs
whs
Posts: 10351

There is really no reason to go back to an old vintage OS. Vista is far superior in Security, Ease of use and Function. XP is slightly better in performance (but also not in all areas) and it uses less RAM. And, the stability of Vista with SP1 is flawless.
The only reason I could see to run XP is when you have a lot of "must have" programs that do not run on Vista.
Edit: See also this thread http://www.howtogeek.com/forum.....?replies=1

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
ScottW
ScottW
Posts: 6609

Vista with SP1 is stable and reliable. It has increased security features and all new features coming from MS and it's partners will be deployed on Vista. Once you get over the learning curve, the day-to-day operation of Vista is no worse than XP.
BUT: Vista has higher hardware requirements and a steep learning curve. There are still applications that are not compatible and older hardware that may never have Vista drivers.

XP with SP2 is even more stable, widely used and tested, and it has lower hardware requirements. Assuming you already know XP, you have already forgotten the learning curve from way back when. No new features will be coming from MS, et. al., but 3rd party companies will fill the gap for a long time. XP is compatible with older hardware and software.
BUT: XP goes end-of-life in less than a week. Support will continue, but it may be hard to find a new copy should you need it. Depending on your system, it may be difficult to find drivers for the hardware because if Vista was pre-installed the maker is unlikely to carry XP drivers on their website. You may just be putting off the inevitable and when you have to move up (at work, for example) you will be behind. Windows 7 is vaporware until it ships so it has no bearing on this decision.

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
cobija
Posts: 320

but vista really needs to fix there capability issues because its driving alot of people crazy. its not only there fault, but the third party vendors

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
whs
whs
Posts: 10351

What "capability issue" are you talking about?

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
cobija
Posts: 320

programs that dont work with vista, not updated drivers, etc.

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
GaardCeteru
GaardCeteru
Posts: 135

Until now... I must say I've only had 1 compatibility problem with vista, and it happened with a VERY VERY VERY old printer. Then all other problems have been fixed by clickin on *Run this program in compatibility mode for: "XP (SP2)" * I have even installed some really crappy old software my mom and some friends of mine use and found no problem on it. To me vista works just great and is not the pest everyone said it would be, only thing is the big memory consumptyon but, then, I have 2GB ram so vista only gets to ticke on it a bit.

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
Aleeve
Aleeve
Posts: 2782

Most of these compatibility issues are now fixed, and I have only ever had one problem with a USB mouse, which I was able to fix pretty promptly anyway
Also, that was fixed with SP1!

I think it would be really silly to downgrade from Vista - as whs mentioned, the ease of use is fantastic, security has been tightened hugely and if you need any other reason not to, how could you choose not to have aero!

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
whs
whs
Posts: 10351

Understand. But life has to go on and you cannot expect that any old stone age device is being supported forever. And as far as programs go, the compatibility mode is already a major accomodation. I think the problem may be worse the other way around. With a recent modern PC you may be struggeling more to get drivers for XP. I think the best strategy is to stay on XP with an older PC and go with Vista with a modern PC - which usually has sufficient resources for Vista, especially RAM.

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
Aleeve
Aleeve
Posts: 2782

Vista needs 2GB to run at a decent kind of speed
obviously it will still run ok at lower RAM specs, but it will be very annoying!
Also, almost all new PCs/Laptops being sold now have 2gb of ram
so i wouldnt worry

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
raphoenix
raphoenix
Posts: 5223

My O/S thoughts are these:
Use XP3 as my work horse.
Use Vista Ultimate (finances permitting) to play with and be short term compatible.
Learn and use Ubantu Linux or (Debian) to prepare for the future which is almost now.
Clean Install each O/S on it's own primary partition in a triple boot configuration plus have a compressed clean image backup of each partition located on a separate hard drive.
With this being said, then we could address and discuss hardware which would also be an "interesting" issue unto its' self. Just my own opinion.

Regards,
Rick P.

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
cwalk
Posts: 14

i would recommend vista over xp, because support for xp is soon gonna detiorate.

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
cobija
Posts: 320

just few of the things really really annoy me. I will just randomly burn a video and windows will freeze it and say that its trying to hack it. Ive tried partitioning but ive been unsucessful. ive tried 2 methods, the vista partition tool and gparted.

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
ScottW
ScottW
Posts: 6609

cobija, maybe you could start a new thread for each of the 2 annoying issues. If we can help you resolve those, perhaps Vista will end up being a good choice for you.

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
cobija
Posts: 320

I started a thread about the partioning issue but i recieved very little help. All people told me was to go and view tutorials. i tried the gparted one and i almost ruined my computer. But the first issue isnt really a big deal. it rarely happens

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
jraparrish
Posts: 82

The Linux learning curve is much worse than Vista. Not to mention, hardware drivers being harder to find. With the exception of the Ubuntu distros, Linux is the polar opposite of the MAC OS, and Windows falls somewhere in the middle. If you have nothing else to do, install Linux and play with it. You will find very few Corporate Enterprises, if any, that are willing to spend the money and/or time to deploy a Linux solution to the desktop. I have used Linux, Windows and MAC, and prefer for ease of use, Windows. To each his own.

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
whs
whs
Posts: 10351

jraparrish, there are more and more goverment agencies (and big ones) that switch to Linux. I guess because of the open source. And by the way: I love Vista.

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
cobija
Posts: 320

as i said, i posted a topic on the partioning and i got little to no help..

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
ScottW
ScottW
Posts: 6609

cobija, I see your thread about partitioning and I'll post over there with assistance. I still think you should post about the other issue because (1) if it annoys you, it's worth asking about and (2) I have been burning videos for a long time and I'm curious to know what's happening.

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 
jraparrish
Posts: 82

In the US?

Posted 1 year ago #
Top
 

RSS feed for this topic

Reply »

You must log in to post.

Our Friends
Getting Started


About How-To Geek
What Is That Process?
svchost.exe
jusched.exe
dwm.exe
ctfmon.exe
wmpnetwk.exe
mDNSResponder.exe
wmpnscfg.exe
rundll32.exe
wfcrun32.exe
Ipoint.exe
Itype.exe
Wfica32.exe
Mobsync.exe
conhost.exe
Dpupdchk.exe Adobe_Updater.exe

Copyright © 2006-2009 HowToGeek.com. All Rights Reserved.