Subscribe to How-To Geek

Welcome to the How-To Geek Forums

We encourage you to register on our forums and post any questions you might have. The How-To Geeks monitor this forum and will respond to your question quickly.

How-To Geek Forums » Windows Vista

The Linux "Sound Flaw"

(6 posts)
  • Started 11 months ago by tan2x
  • Latest reply from jd2066
  • Topic Viewed 250 times

tan2x
Posts: 57

A lot of my friends asked me about the faulty detection of Linux when it comes to sound. Even on my experience, popular Linux distros like Ubuntu failed to do so. The problem starts after installing and booting Linux on a hard drive partition. Startup sound loops abnormally and it accumulates very distracting series of looping sounds when another sound is being played (i.e. event sounds or playing music files). As a remedy, I sought every possible solutions but nothing worked. I installed linux driver for the sound card, modified combinations of sound configs and even reinstalling the whole Linux. Thats why with this problem, I discarded Linux as an alternative OS. The question is, what would be the perfect Linux distro that has no "sound flaw"?

Here's the list of popular sound cards that cannot be detected properly by Linux:
Realtek HD Sound
Realtek AC'97

Drivers that failed:
ALSA

Linux s**t Distros:
Ubuntu
OpenSUSE
Gentoo
Pardus

Posted 11 months ago #
Top
 
thegeek
The Geek
Posts: 1887

I don't believe there's any distribution that has no flaws when it comes to sound support. The fact is, Linux is just not great when it comes to sound, video, or print drivers... sure, they are usually supported, but the support is buggy or incomplete.

Posted 11 months ago #
Top
 
tan2x
Posts: 57

Anyway, making a free OS does not mean full attainment of user's needs. Thanks Geek!

Posted 11 months ago #
Top
 
jd2066
Justin
Posts: 3792

In my experiance the sound support works just fine with Linux. The video also works with an NVIDIA card. Had a really hard time getting a mobile ATI video card to work and it still doesn't work right.
From what I've read, this happens because not many manufactours make Linux drivers so it's up to the Linux developers to wrote many of the drivers themselfs.
Probably due to the low market share of Linux.
Which makes a bit of a catch 22, people don't want to use an OS that doesn't work well with their hardware and manufactors don't want to make drivers for an OS that not a lot of people use.

Posted 11 months ago #
Top
 
thegeek
The Geek
Posts: 1887

The sound support has always worked fine for me in linux, but I've read a ton of horror stories... and it usually only supports very basic sound options for most video cards, no surround or anything else.

Posted 11 months ago #
Top
 
jd2066
Justin
Posts: 3792

Ok. I've never really checked if the rest worked. Normal Stereo output is fine for me.

Posted 11 months ago #
Top
 

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.

Our Friends
Getting Started


About How-To Geek
What Is That Process?
svchost.exe
jusched.exe
dwm.exe
ctfmon.exe
wmpnetwk.exe
mDNSResponder.exe
wmpnscfg.exe
rundll32.exe
wfcrun32.exe
Ipoint.exe
Itype.exe
Wfica32.exe
Mobsync.exe
conhost.exe
Dpupdchk.exe Adobe_Updater.exe

Copyright © 2006-2009 HowToGeek.com. All Rights Reserved.