SEARCH

How-To Geek

HTG Explains: How Does Dynamic Range Compression Change Audio?

banner

Dynamic Range Compression is used in everything. Most audio editors have a “compressor effect,” and mastering it can mean the difference between an amateur and pro-level mix. To understand how it works, we need to see what exactly it does.

Dynamic Range Compression

First of all, this should not be confused with general “audio compression,” which is data compression and covers things like MP3 conversion. We’re most definitely NOT talking about compression of quality for space-saving reasons. If that’s what you’re looking for, check out HTG Explains: What Are the Differences Between All Those Audio Formats?

We are talking about compression of the dynamic range of sound in an audio track. If you record a pin-drop followed by a TNT explosion, you’ll notice that there’s a very large difference in the intensities of those two sounds. That’s what we refer to as dynamic range. Now, our ears are pretty good at working with large differences like that, but audio equipment isn’t. If you ever watched a war movie where the actors’ dialogue was drowned out by gunfire, then you know what I’m talking about. Granted, that would be difficult to hear in real life as well, but the audio equipment involved in the process makes it pretty unintelligible. That’s where a compressor comes in.

Atomisonic_Dynoray_Front_Panel

The image above shows a rack-mounted compressor, which will take an audio signal and adjust it based on several parameters. It’s a lot like having a personal audio engineer that will constantly adjust the signal to where it “should” be, as it’s running through the system. Compressors are usually physical devices that process signals that can be chained to other effects and processors, but the effect can also be applied via software. You can adjust the levels he starts to turn the knobs at, how quickly he acts, and how much compression is applied over what time period, but that’s what his focus is limited to. This reduces the dynamic range in predetermined ways so that the result is uniform audio, or at least audio whose loud and soft ends are much closer to each other.

As an Effect

Compressors can be used for artistic effect, too. It can enable singers to whisper just as loud as the distorted guitar. This result that wouldn’t really work as well by just adjusting the volume, especially if the singer suddenly switched from whisper to all out scream. Let’s take a look at some examples.

Listen at around 0:43 for the bass drum; you’ll heard the rest of the track’s volume drop.

For the Killers’ benefit, I’ll assume the effect here is intentional. You can hear when the bass drum kicks starting around 43 seconds in that the volume of everything else drops a bit. This particular use is often heard in the various techno-subgenres to accent beats. Though its use can be deliberate, this “pumping” is most often a sign of a badly- or over-compressed song

Listen for the lead singer’s high-powered vocal at 0:22, and a low-powered one at 1:29.

At 22 seconds in, you can hear Amy Lee push a high-powered vocal that’s close to a scream, but it sounds muted. At 1:29, you can hear the layered background vocals being whispered, but the volume is normal. And, of course, you can hear that pumping effect while the audience is clapping throughout the video.

Both of these examples show what DRC can do in isolated circumstances, i.e. as an effect on a particular clip. It’s somewhat harder to illustrate how compression is utilized in its more mainstream usage.

Constant Volume

clipping_compared_to_limiting

Image illustrating various compressor configurations to limit volume (from Wikimedia Commons)

DRC works well as a more advanced volume limiter that prevents the signal from clipping, which can distort the sound quality and damage sensitive equipment. It’s universally used to smooth out an audio track so that when an equalizer is applied afterwards, you reap more of the benefits. DRC is also used in movies so that in loud scenes, you can still hear the actors’ dialogue, or so that the dying whisper of a victim is still loud and clear after the gunshot that ended him. It can still preserve some of the dynamic effects, however. Let’s take the example of a band.

The drums are a really dynamic and overall loud part of a band. If the drum track is uneven, it’s pretty noticeable. Say the drummer’s tired or makes some slight mistakes throughout the track. Some parts of the track will have louder bass kicks than others. Using a compressor will even that out so that the lighter kicks will be just as loud as the normal ones, and the harder kicks will be toned down a bit. Snares can also by toned down by dampening the initial strike, thus allowing the “crack” that follows to become more prominent.

On a bass guitar, the higher notes will be louder and punchier than the lower ones. A compressor will keep the low tones loud and higher ones soft. On the other hand, when you use slaps to accent, you can keep them from spiking too high and being distracting, but still keep them sharper than the normal bass notes. You can also increase how long the note is sustained at a higher volume.

Guitarists often can get carried away with their playing. Compressors can make sure that the lightly plucked or strummed notes stay light and the heavier ones stay loud. After a certain point, heavy strumming starts to distort the audio. Setting the compressor’s threshold – more on that later – to less than that will prevent entranced guitarists from messing up the track. You can also alter the sustain.

In the same vein as the bass guitar, singers tend to sing louder at higher pitches and softer at lower pitches, depending on their range. You can keep the singer’s pitches even without requiring the singer to put more or less power behind them.

In these ways, dynamic range compression can be used to smooth out smaller fluctuations in performance by artists. This allows a more uniform sound but still allows musicians to deliberately emphasize certain notes and cadences. It doesn’t get rid of the dynamic range of sounds completely, it just makes it so that the musician has to put more effort into it. All of this is especially important at live shows where performances are highly variable and much more sensitive to the performers’ stamina and frame of mind.

Listen to the first 20 seconds, focusing on the change between the intro and the rest of the song.

In this example, the Cancer Bats decided to compress the dynamic range over the whole song, not one particular track. Pay close attention to the end of the intro, at around 14 seconds in. The guitar is loud when it’s in focus, but as the rest of the instruments kick in, it drops down and mixes in. The overall volume of the song doesn’t change through the transition. You’ll hear a bit of pumping, too, but not as much as in the other songs. Unless this is the specific effect you’re going for, this is often considered a “poor” use of compression.

Listen to the end of the solo intro at about 0:07.

Here, Daath used DRC over individual instrument tracks. You can tell because the guitar in the first few seconds of the song is a particular volume, and it’s maintained through the rest of the song. Unlike the Cancer Bats’ song above, Daath’s song gets louder when the other instruments come in by a more noticeable amount. This is good example of “good” compression; as the Futurama quote goes, “When you do things right, people won’t be sure you’ve done anything at all.”

Ultimately, it depends on what you want. Professionals say that compression should be used on each individual track, then if needed, over the final track as a whole. Dynamic range is good because it adds flair, nuance, and color to audio. Compression is used to illustrate that where musicians want it to be, and that’s done by reducing variation elsewhere. On the other hand, compression can add its own effect to audio. Several artists and even the majority of some genres use this for a specific feel, as an artistic effect.

Compression Parameters

drc in audacity

Compressors are built in different ways. Some use tubes, others use valves, some use light sensors and LEDs, and the cheaper ones use solid state parts. Different types of DRCs will “color” the sound differently, albeit slightly. The goal isn’t to change the sound itself, of course, but having an expensive tube compressor that makes the audio sound warmer certainly won’t hurt. Whether cheap or expensive and regardless of the mechanism, they all work to see the signal and adjust the volume. Compressor effects essentially mimic hardware compressors; above you can see the pane for the compressor effect in Audacity. Both focus on a handful of parameters.

Threshold: This is the level at which the compressor will act. This can be set to the minimum or maximum volume, but it’s more commonly used as a guide post at which the compressor enacts changes. After this point, increases (or decreases, if used to bump upwards) in volume are significantly dampened.

Ratio: This is ratio by which the exceeding output is reduced. A 20:1 ratio will reduce whatever exceeds the threshold by that much, so 20db over the threshold will come out of the compressor as 1db over. Because the decibel system is logarithmic, this is has a much more pronounced effect on the volume. Really high ratios, like 20:1, 60:1, or infinity:1, effectively hard limit the volume.

Attack: The signal isn’t altered by the compressor immediately; there’s a slight delay. Attack allows you to control this delay. It’s measured usually in milliseconds, so higher values will allow spikes of volume through the threshold before behind compressed, making guitars sound more punchy. Lower values will help with hard limiting.

Audio_Compression_Attack_and_Release-2

Image diagramming a compressed signal in comparison to its original signal (from Wikimedia Commons)

Release: Compressed sound can be immediately returned to their actual volume or they can held at the threshold for longer. Using a higher value for release will help increase the “sustain” of a guitar or bass, allowing for notes to be held out much longer.

Knee: The Attack dictates how quickly the compressor will act on a signal that exceeds the threshold. Knee dictates how quickly the compression is applied to that signal. A “hard” knee means that as soon as the compressor acts, it fully compresses the signal. This works well when using the compressor as a volume limiter. A “soft” knee will gradually build to using full compression. This keeps vocals sounding natural despite using compression.

Output: This is the output level, which can be modified. After compressing a track or signal, it can be brought back up to its full volume or cut to a lower one.

Different instruments sound more “natural” with specific settings, of course. Do some research online and use your ear to experiment until you find the sound you want. You have to ask yourself “What does my track need?” Now that you know how dynamic range compression works, you can tinker with the sound for yourself.

If you’re looking for more info, there’s a great post on the Seven Strings guitar forum on DRC.

Yatri Trivedi is a monk-like geek. When he's not overdosing on meditation and geek news of all kinds, he's hacking and tweaking something, often while mumbling in 4 or 5 other languages.

  • Published 04/5/11

Comments (10)

  1. Ivan Kolevski

    Great tutorial/explanation. Loved it. This brings old memories when I used to do lots of audio/midi recordings. Wavegain tool is very useful and mp3gain as well. Cheers, Ivan K.

  2. Jim Smith

    Great article. I do a one-man podcast and I have a compressor/expander in the signal stream, but the 14 knobs of the thing were always a bit daunting and I never seem to get it “just right”. This article, like your other articles, was very helpful and simplifies the process. To paraphrase Dr. McCoy “I’m a talker, not an engineer”.

  3. John

    Is these any software that can “undo” the dynamic compression on music? I mean, is it possible to broad the differences between loud and loudest instruments in a song?

  4. Groff

    Thumbs up for Daath! The effect is MUCH more prominent listening to the CD than the youtube video. Youtube has a tendency to compress audio a bit :-\

    @John It’s impossible on something with multiple tracks because it’s usually applied in a mastering chain over everything and mixed down into stereo audio.

  5. Mike

    Compression is the curse of broadcasting. I HATE listening to broadcast stations which use compression. That includes MOST of them. Some community stations don’t. And maybe this is why so many people today are going back to their old vinyl records. Much less compression was used in the days of vinyl, if you discount the RIAA curve.

    And TV commercials which are compressed to the max! Aaaaargh! In Australia, “Harvey Norman” and “Domayne” stores are the worst. I mute their ads and refuse to visit their stores…

  6. fant0mas

    great article! helped me understand compression far better than I did before (which was almost zero ^^).

    you should do some sort of round-up for all audio / recording related articles on HTG! couldn´t really find any more, though I am pretty sure you already had some of these – the “related articles” features sucks balls in this regard, sorry to say so.

    this sort of stuff helps low-budget autodidact – musicians / engineers like myself to get better results out of our home recording projects.
    thanks!

  7. Withanamelikedave

    This article just dominated my cube. Outside world was unaware.

  8. Felipe

    @Mike
    blame the people, not the tool.
    you can refer to the “loudness wars”, but that’s a different topic.
    compression is REALLY useful (I’m an acoustician), but is not a curse, it’s a tool ;)

  9. MajorBuzz

    I’ve found using a compressor for DJ work to be invaluable. Setting it properly will in effect balance the volume from different albums or CD’s that have been recorded at different levels. This will also work when balancing audio files or when using multiplay CD players.

  10. Joe

    Thank you so much for this explanation/tutorial. It really is well-explained and thorough and above all, incredibly heplful.

Enter Your Email Here to Get Access for Free:

Go check your email!